Brokers and the Market Cycle: Navigating a Changing Market

As we move further into 2025, insurance brokers are facing a complex and changing landscape. From digital disruption and shifting customer expectations toregulatory pressures and recruitment challenges, brokers are balancing multiple priorities. But one issue continues to influence daily operations and strategy: the softening insurance market.

Market conditions might not make headlines like Consumer Duty or AI, but impact how brokers trade. As rates begin to fall and capacity increases, brokers must adjust their approach to remain resilient. This requires a strong understanding of the insurance market cycle.

‍

Why the Market Cycle Still Matters

‍

The insurance market cycle swings between hard and soft market conditions. A hard market typically means rising premiums, tighter underwriting, and reduced capacity. In contrast, a soft market is characterised by falling premiums, broader terms, and increased competition among insurers.

Many brokers have spent recent years in a hard market shaped by pandemic recovery,inflation, and reinsurance pressures. But now, signs of softening are becomingmore visible. This shift can catch teams off guard—especially if they haven’tseen this side of the cycle before.

Understanding the cycle is not just theoretical. It impacts:

• Client conversations:     Customers become more price-sensitive and shop around.
• Placement strategy:     Insurers broaden risk appetites, but inconsistencies can emerge.
• Negotiation and servicing:     Margins narrow, so attention to detail becomes critical.

‍

The ability to maintain strong relationships, deliver value beyond price, and give sound commercial advice becomes even more important.

‍

Bridging the Knowledge Gap

‍

Many brokers, especially those newer to the profession, haven’t received structured training on the market cycle, what drives it, or how to adapt strategy.Experienced brokers, meanwhile, may need to reassess old habits that no longerapply.

This is where targeted learning and development plays a vital role. CPD-accredited training, mentoring programmes, and collaborative knowledge-sharing sessions can equip brokers to:

• Tailor conversations to reflect market conditions
• Adjust renewal approaches with confidence
• Avoid the risk of underinsurance driven by price-only focus

Brokers who understand these principles perform better and feel more credible and confident in front of clients and insurers.

‍

Preparing for What’s Next

No broker can predict exactly how the market will evolve. Global economic volatility, climate-driven risk, reinsurance trends, and regulatory reforms will all continue to shape conditions. But brokers who understand how the s theory with practice—scenario-based learning that helps brokers respond to real-time conditions.

Investment in training isn’t a “nice-to-have”, it’s a strategic priority. Brokers who understand the fundamentals will not only adapt more quickly but also build lasting trust with clients and trading partners.

As 2025 unfolds, now is the time to re-engage with the market cycle and build the knowledge and confidence to thrive in whatever conditions come next.

‍