Evidencing competence: 5 mistakes insurance firms make

Evidencing competence: 5 mistakes insurance firms make

Logged hours and completions don't show competence. Learn five mistakes UK insurance firms make when evidencing competence, and what good evidence looks like.

In our UK Insurance Skills & Competency Index 2026, 99% of respondents said they were confident their firm consistently meets mandatory CPD and regulatory learning requirements. Yet 41% said their single greatest compliance-learning challenge relates to tracking, measuring or evidencing learning.

Both can be true. A firm can be sure its people have done the required training and still find it hard to show what that training achieved.

That gap matters more now. The FCA has removed the 15-hour CPD minimum for non-investment and non-qualified insurance staff, so counting hours no longer shows that the standard is met. You need to show that your people are competent for their roles.

This article covers five common mistakes firms make when evidencing competence, what to do instead, and what good evidence looks like.

Key takeaways

  • Since 9 December 2025, non-investment and non-CII qualified insurance staff no longer have an FCA 15-hour CPD minimum, but the competent employees rule still applies.
  • Hours, completions and satisfaction scores record participation. Competence needs evidence of how learning is applied at work.
  • Good evidence links four things: a defined need, the learning itself, an assessment of how it's applied at work, and any follow-up.
  • Reassess when duties change and keep the depth of evidence proportionate to the role's risk.
  • A clear competence record also helps you to evidence how staff capability supports good customer outcomes under the Consumer Duty.

What changed in December 2025, and what didn't

  • The FCA's policy statement PS25/21, Simplifying the insurance rules, removed the mandatory 15-hour annual CPD requirement for non-investment and non-CII qualified insurance personnel. The change also removed the related monitoring and record-keeping requirements
  • The duty to keep people competent did not change. In PS25/21, the FCA says the proposal "is not intended as a relaxation of the overall competence and training expectation in our rules". Firms must still provide appropriate ongoing training under the competent employees rule in SYSC 5.1, and SYSC 28 still applies.

Some staff still have a set number of hours to complete each year. The Handbook keeps a 15-hour minimum for life and long-term insurance staff. Members of professional bodies such as the CII also keep their own mandatory CPD requirements, which the CII says the FCA's decision does not change.

For everyone else, you now decide what appropriate training looks like for each role. You also need to be able to explain that decision.

Five mistakes firms make when evidencing competence

Each of these mistakes is easy to make, because each one produces a record that looks complete. The problem is what the record leaves out.

1. Treating hours or completions as proof of competence

Hours and completion records show that someone took part in learning. They don't show that the person understood it or can apply it in their role. An account handler can complete a Consumer Duty module and still struggle to explain cover clearly to a customer.

Completion records are still worth keeping. They form part of the record and help you track who has covered what. The problem comes when they are the whole record.

What to do instead: keep your completion data, and add a check of understanding and application. A scenario-based assessment, for example, asks a learner to work through a realistic case study and shows whether they can apply what they learned. File reviews and call monitoring do the same for live work.

2. Relying on satisfaction scores

Satisfaction scores measure how learners reacted to a course. They don't measure what changed in their work afterwards.

In the Index, 84% of respondents rated their learning programme as very or extremely effective. The survey doesn't show how they judged that, and the confidence is only as strong as the measures behind it.

Evidence of understanding and application shows what the training achieved. That is a stronger answer when a board, an auditor or a client asks.

What to do instead: define the outcome before training starts, then assess against it. If the aim is clearer explanations of cover, check how well people now explain it. If the aim is more for reliable checking of AI-generated material, assess whether people spot the errors and can explain the checks they made.

3. Training without a defined role need

If you can't say why someone needed a piece of training, it's hard to show that it made them more competent in their role.

With the hours minimum gone, firms have more freedom to tailor development. That freedom comes with a question you should be ready to answer: why was this training right for this person's role?

What to do instead: start with the role. Set out what competent performance looks like for each role using a competency framework, then run a training needs analysis to find the gaps. Training assigned against those gaps has a clear reason behind it, and that reason becomes the first link in your evidence.

4. Assuming a complete record still applies after duties change

A complete training record reflects the role someone held when they did the training. When their duties change, the record may no longer cover what they now need to do.

Common changes that should prompt a review include:

  • a promotion or a move into a new team
  • new products or new lines of business
  • new tools, including AI, that change how a task is done
  • new regulatory responsibilities, such as an SM&CR function
  • an incident or a long absence

‍

What to do instead: review capability whenever a role, tool or product changes, as well as at the annual review. Someone with a full record may still need further development for their new responsibilities.

5. Expecting a platform to establish competence by itself

A learning platform can organise training needs analysis, learning and assessment records, but on its own, it can't establish that someone is competent.

Managers play a large part. They need to understand the expected standard, see how people perform, give useful feedback and make time for learning to be applied. Without that, a well-kept platform still holds an incomplete picture.

What to do instead: use the platform to hold the evidence chain together, and give managers a clear role in it. The platform keeps the need, the learning and the assessment in one record. Managers still set the standard, observe the work and record the feedback.

What good competence evidence looks like

Good evidence of competence connects a defined need, the learning provided, an assessment of how it's applied at work, and any follow-up. That chain gives you a fuller account of capability than course records alone. It also helps you explain your approach when a regulator, auditor or client asks.

The need

Start with what the role requires and where the person falls short. Sources include your competency framework, a training needs analysis, file review findings and complaints data.

The learning

Record what was done to close the gap and why it fits that need. This might be a course, a webinar, coaching or a supervised piece of work.

Applied at work

Assess whether the person can now do the task to the expected standard. Use scenario-based assessments, observed calls, file-checks or supervisor sign-off.

Follow-up

Where a gap remains, record the further support agreed and when you'll review it. Where the standard is met, record that too, with a date for the next review.

Keep it proportionate

Match the depth of evidence to the role's risk and its effect on customers. The aim is a reasonable account of what the learning achieved, enough to inform the next development decision.

Stage Question it answers Example evidence
Need Why did this person need this learning? Competency framework gap, TNA result, file review finding
Learning What was done to close the gap? Course or webinar record, coaching notes, supervised task
Applied at work Can they now do the task to the standard? Scenario-based assessment, call monitoring, file check, manager sign-off
Follow-up What happens next? Further development agreed, review date, reassessment result

An illustrative example

An account handler moves from personal lines to commercial lines:

  • Need: a training needs analysis shows gaps in commercial property cover and in assessing business interruption exposures.
  • Learning: their manager assigns two targeted courses, a knowledge assessment and a period of supervised work on new business.
  • Applied at work: after six weeks, a file review checks three of their cases. Two meet the expected standard, and the third shows a gap in explaining policy exclusions.
  • Follow-up: the manager agrees further coaching and sets a review date.

The manager records each step, so the firm can show why the learning was needed and what it achieved.

A file that answers all four questions is easier to defend than a list of courses. It also gives managers better data for appraisals and development conversations.

How a competence record supports Consumer Duty

The Consumer Duty asks firms to deliver good outcomes for customers and to be able to evidence them. Staff training and competence is one of the ways firms deliver those outcomes.  

A competence record helps you evidence that competence but the FCA has flagged gaps here. Its March 2025 review of the consumer support outcome found that some firms "failed to evidence appropriate training and other measures". Those measures help staff understand their role in delivering good outcomes (FCA, Consumer support outcome: good practices and areas for improvement).  

A record that links each need, the learning completed, an assessment of how it's applied and any follow-up helps close that gap. When complaints, file reviews or call quality checks show a problem, you can check whether a skills gap is behind it. If it is, you assign targeted training, assess how it's applied, and record the result.

Over time, that gives your board and Consumer Duty champion a clear view of how capability is being managed against customer outcomes.

Next steps

Check your current records against the four stages and see where the links are missing. To see how a learning platform built for insurance can hold that evidence chain, book a demo and get a free trial.

‍

ACCREDITATIONS
APCC Affiliate LogoMGAA Member LogoDiscovery Insights Logo